20 November 2026
The document that wants to kill European civil society
On Tuesday 24 November, the Committee on Budgetary Control (CONT) of the European Parliament will vote on a document that could give a fatal blow to European civil society and pluralism. This working document published by the Scrutiny Working Group (SWG) on NGO funding following a veritable witch-hunt set up by the EPP, hand in hand with the far right, seeks to neutralise the main counterweight to their agenda of environmental deregulation. The document explicitly calls to cut off EU public funding; to sharply restrict operating grants and prevent environmental NGOs from applying for them; and to ostracise NGOs from European democratic debate.
In May 2026, BLOOM published an extensive investigation on the broader political dynamics at play in the set-up of the SWG, “Operation: European Chaos”. The co-authors of the SWG working document, EPP MEP Dirk Gotink and ECR MEP Carlo Fidanza now classify “[providing] voting recommendations and counterarguments to balance industry’s influence” as a “reputational risk” for EU institutions, and henceforth seek to ban civil society from participating in European legislative processes, while imposing no comparable restrictions on corporate actors and business lobbies. This document is a smoking gun in the hands of the EPP and far-right coalition, proving their subservience to industrial lobbies. This is a watershed document that threatens to wreak havoc the EU conduct of democratic debate.
On Friday 12 November, an explosive document with potentially disastrous implications for the European rule of law emerged from the corridors of the European Parliament: a working document of the Scrutiny Working Group (SWG), set up within the Committee on Budgetary Control (CONT) in November 2025 by the European conservative and far right. Created specifically to discredit civil society organisations, and environmental NGOs in particular, while lending a veneer of seriousness and legitimacy, the SWG sets out its conclusions and recommendations resulting from a year’s work in a document which is deeply troubling for the future of European democracy.
The fact that the illiberal and reactionary far right is openly at war with civil society, non-governmental organisations and independent watchdogs is, however grave, hardly surprising. It is in their very nature. Far more troubling is that a policy of this kind, which attacks democratic governance at its core by undermining pluralism and the participation of independent actors in the political and legislative process, is being pursued by the European People’s Party (EPP), while belonging to a political family that presents itself as a defender of the rule of law and of the founding principles of the European project.
A vote to either approve or reject this document will be held in Strasbourg, on Tuesday 24 November, in the Committee on Budgetary Control (CONT) of the European Parliament. If it were to be adopted, this document would stamp its unfounded accusations with a seal of Parliamentary legitimacy, along with recommendations that would, in short, deal a potentially fatal blow to the galaxy of European NGOs and to the project of a plural, vibrant democratic society on which the European Union is founded.
The origins of the SWG
The Scrutiny Working Group on NGO funding was explicitly created to attack the civil society organisations that defend EU environmental policies and oppose the deregulation agenda being pushed through at full speed by the EPP hand in hand with European far-right groups. As BLOOM demonstrated in “Operation: European Chaos”, the SWG emerged as the culmination of a long, multi-year campaign waged by the EPP against environmental organisations, which now finds its best ally among the illiberal political groups in order to bring the offensive to a conclusion.
Among its members are some of the MEPs closest to the leadership of the EPP such as Dirk Gotink (former spokesperson of EPP President Manfred Weber) and Monika Hohlmeier (German MEP from the CSU, Manfred Weber’s party). Other prominent figures from the most illiberal parties in Europe feature: Carlo Fidanza (Giorgia Meloni’s right-hand man in Brussels, close to neo-fascist movements in Italy), Csaba Dömötör (from the party of Viktor Orbán, notorious for persecuting independent and critical associations in Hungary before the April 2026 elections) and Julien Sanchez (a leading figure of the Rassemblement National).
The casus belli for the SWG’s work was a set of insinuations, developed first and foremost by Dirk Gotink and the EPP, according to which the European Commission, and in particular its Directorates-General for the Environment and for Climate action, had funded environmental NGOs on the promise that they would push for the implementation of the Green Deal in the European Parliament and the Council, as well as in other Directorates-General of the Commission itself. Gotink called this practice “shadow lobbying”. It was clearly refuted by the SWG’s own investigations, which failed to produce any proof or evidence that such NGO instrumentalisation ever existed.
The MEPs of the liberal (Renew), socialist (S&D), green (Greens/EFA) and left (The Left) groups who were initially supposed to participate in the SWG as Members of the European Parliament’s Control Committee, walked out of the SWG at the outset of its inaugural session, on 26 November 2025, in order to boycott what they described as an inquisitorial tribunal conducting a witch hunt against civil society and undermining the foundations of European pluralist democracy.
The vote due to be held on 24 November on the SWG working document thus represents a historic testing ground for the convergence of the EPP with the far right, and for the slide of the European Parliament’s largest group towards dangerously illiberal and reactionary positions.
The SWG’s recommendations: a death sentence for EU civil society
At the heart of the SWG working document, 23 recommendations are elaborated to ostracise independent non-governmental organisations from the European institutions. Among them, the most significant and problematic are:
- An attack on NGO advocacy within the European institutions: Recommendation 3 calls for the incorporation of “binding restrictions on targeted advocacy towards EU institutions into all relevant EU funding and procurement documents”. If applied, it would tie the hands of every organisation receiving EU public funding, preventing them from carrying out any public-interest work or bringing their positions and proposals to the Union’s decision-making bodies, and rendering them fundamentally inoperative.
- An attack on NGO participation to the European democratic life: Recommendation 7 adds to the restrictions of Recommendation 3 a demand to “[ban] funding of lobbying to the EU and national institutions with the EU funds” and exclude from financing for at least 5 years all organisations breaching this norm. This would effectively subject NGOs to blackmail: they would either lose all the funding necessary for their operations and for carrying out the projects developed in collaboration with European institutions, or, alternatively, find themselves effectively muzzled and deprived of their freedom of speech and advocacy. It is of particular concern that this recommendation applies to all organisations that receive European public funding, and carry out any form of advocacy and technical support towards not only EU policymakers, but also at national level in the Member States.
- An attack on environmental watchdogs: Recommendation 4 expressly calls for a strong limitation on the award of operating grants (public funding intended to cover an organisation’s everyday overhead, staff salaries, rent and core mission activities rather than a single restricted project) and for restricting such funding to organisations working on humanitarian aid, poverty reduction and other social causes. In the document’s own words, it asks to “[limit] to the maximum extent possible the use of operating grants and require maintenance of separate accounts for EU financing. Only a limited number of EU financed programmes shall allow for operating grants, such as those related to humanitarian aid, fighting poverty or other social causes within the EU’s competencies and based on the codification of the Commission Guidelines.” The aim is clear: to cut off the oxygen of the organisations working on environmental, anti-corruption and similar topics, at the centre of this working group’s inquiry.
More broadly, this set of recommendations would impose a series of administrative restrictions and obligations that would vastly limit the freedom of action and freedom of expression of non-governmental organisations working on EU policies and institutions, making their work virtually impossible. It is all the more troubling given that at no point does the SWG working document require comparable restrictions or obligations for private economic actors or for lobbying entities defending commercial and industrial interests. Corporate actors routinely advocate before the European institutions and benefit just as extensively from Commission grants, notably action grants aimed at research and the implementation of EU programmes such as Horizon, all while being able to rely on their own substantial resources.
Banning funding for NGOs, which pursue no economic interest, and therefore have limited financial resources, while creating no immediate and wide-ranging restriction on the private sector, deliberately creates an uneven democratic playing field allowing for unchecked corporate capture to proceed unabated in the coming years.
A sham process in which the principal accused parties, the NGOs, were never heard
Although the working document claims that NGOs were not the primary target of the investigation, asserting instead that its focus was the European Commission and its allegedly opaque allocation of funds to independent organisations (NGOs, foundations, think tanks, companies, universities and research organisations), the document targets almost exclusively NGOs, with a specific focus on environmental organisations.
From its very first page, the document attempts to shield itself from accusations of attacking NGOs, specifically stating:
“NGOs have not been invited to give their perspectives as they were not the main objective of the SWG; the process of the disbursement of EU funds by the European Commission to specific stakeholders in the Brussels lobby circuit was.”
Yet this defence merely highlights the weakness of its own position. Across 70 pages, the working document repeatedly attacks NGOs while completely ignoring cases of public funding awarded to the “other entities” it claims to scrutinise.
The affirmation, repeated throughout the text, that the SWG’s mandate is “recipient-neutral” is little more than a facade designed to create a perceived objectivity and degree of seriousness. In reality, the body has been wholly instrumentalised to serve a political objective shared by the EPP and the far right, i.e. dismantling the network of environmental NGOs that acts as a countervailing force and an inconvenient obstacle to their broader agenda of rolling back European Union environmental policies.
Of particular concern is the fact that at no point during an entire year of investigations, did the SWG interview the main defendants. Conducting an investigation so overtly directed against NGOs while systematically refusing to hear their defense, explanations or counterarguments leaves little doubt as to the nature of the exercise. This was never a genuine inquiry; it was a political spectacle designed to manufacture allegations, for expelling civil society organisations from the European institutions.
The verdict had been determined before proceedings even began. The working group’s function was merely to legitimise this witch hunt while clearing the way for industrial lobbies and private interests to influence European policymakers without challenge, thereby pushing policies aligned with their economic interests rather than the common good.
An offensive built entirely on insinuation
No breach of the law was identified on the part of either the Commission or the NGOs, despite more than a year-long investigation and four hearings involving officials from several Directorates-General of the European Commission and representatives of the European Court of Auditors.
Nor was any evidence uncovered to support the conspiratorial allegation of the EPP, ECR and PfE parliamentarians sitting in the SWG that the Commission financed NGOs in exchange for promoting the Commission’s policy positions before the other co-legislators, namely the European Parliament and the Council, as well as at national level within EU Member States.
The working document itself explicitly acknowledges that “SWG is not in a position to draw an outright conclusion of a breach of Article 13(2) TEU or of the duty of sincere cooperation” (p. 44). Article 13(2) of the Treaty on European Union requires the EU institutions to act within the limits of the powers conferred on them and to practice mutual sincere cooperation. In other words, the SWG found no evidence supporting claims of a “shadow lobbying” conducted by NGOs on behalf of the Commission within either the European Parliament or the Council.
This complete absence of evidence is reaffirmed several times in the following pages: “The SWG did not, and on this evidence could not, establish that EU funding causally influenced any legislative or policy outcome” (p. 51). Yet, in a remarkable feat of logical acrobatics, and in direct contradiction of its own findings, the document simultaneously advances allegations presented as established facts only a few pages earlier: “There are clear indications and proof, beyond the legality questions, that the EU decision-making process was influenced by entities receiving EU funding and that such funding was employed for such influence” (p. 40). And again: “The SWG can conclude to a certain extent that EU-funded advocacy has caused, willingly or unwillingly, influence over Union decision-making” (p. 47).
The document is riddled with accusations based on suggestions rather than evidence. It refers, for example, to a “perceived conflict of interest” and argues that certain circumstances “fuel speculation about the underlying objectives of the respective grant agreements”. Such language belongs more to the realm of insinuation than real investigation. Speculation is treated as evidence. Perception is elevated to the status of quasi-fact. Suspicions are repeatedly reinforced without proof. For a parliamentary working document, this is a scandalous rhetorical approach.
The entire edifice constructed by the far right and the EPP collapses under the weight of the authors’ own admissions. Yet this has not prevented them from continuing to push unsubstantiated allegations, to the point of suggesting that “the close alignment between the Commission’s policy objectives and the activities pursued by beneficiaries (i.e. the NGOs) raises questions about the extent to which beneficiaries operate at arm’s length or are, in practice, closely integrated into the Commission’s policy agenda.”
The same kind of unfounded accusations, with no mention of the inconclusive results of the inquiry, were voiced by Dirk Gotink when he presented the working document to the SWG on Wednesday 18 November:
“Results confirm what was suspected and knew simply from practice: grants where attributed on the base of work programs that are aligned with very precise political objective from the European Commission and specifically, and I have to say specifically, from DG ENVI and DG CLIM (…) We have in my view a clear picture that the concerns that we had about the separation of powers were absolutely confirmed.“
During this SWG session, MEP Gotink also spoke of a “symbiotic relation” between the European Commission and NGOs, yetno evidence is presented to support this claim. Nevertheless, the SWG proceeds to recommend restricting public funding for NGOs and limiting their ability to carry out legitimate advocacy activities. The culprits had been identified before the investigation began. Their heads were destined to roll regardless of the conclusive evidence. For the SWG members the NGOs have to be stopped from founding the EU legislative process on a wide range of perspectives and expertise and guarantee a democratic process that is inclusive and informed. It is important to stress that the European Commission justifies its funding of European NGOs in terms of creating a “level playing field”: “Non-profit making entities play an important role in raising awareness of environmental issues for better governance. They voice the concerns of EU citizens and ensure their democratic representation. For the development, implementation and proper enforcement of EU environmental or climate policy, there needs to be an open and wide-ranging dialogue with all stakeholders. It is important that organizations are able to take part in such a dialogue, since they represent EU citizens and have a good understanding of public concerns on the environment and climate change. Their presence is important to provide a sound democratic contribution, and a level-playing field with other actors in the EU arena”.
The SWG’s disingenuousness is exposed by the very criteria it chose to apply
The political nature of the exercise becomes even clearer when examining the standards against which the SWG chose to assess the matter.
The investigation evaluated funding arrangements according to four criteria: legality; regularity (compliance with applicable rules and contractual obligations); propriety and sound financial management (whether agreements and grants were “appropriate”, even if lawful and regular); and reputational and institutional risk.
Only the former two of these criteria relate to legal compliance. The latter two are inherently subjective, politically loaded and entirely dependent on ideological interpretation. In effect, the SWG set out not merely to determine whether Commission support for NGOs was lawful, but to establish whether such support was politically acceptable when viewed through the lens of the European conservative and far right. It is therefore unsurprising that any grant agreement between the Commission and organisations opposed to the environmentally destructive and deregulatory agenda promoted by these political forces would be deemed “inappropriate” in their eyes.
The criterion of “reputational and institutional risk” is even more revealing. A reputational risk in whose eyes, and according to whose conception of democratic debate? Throughout the document, this notion is repeated almost as a mantra, yet nowhere is it clearly defined, and the co-authors never explain how supporting a plural, active and vibrant civil society, one that helps balance the influence of powerful lobbying interests and serves as an independent watchdog against abuses of power, could reasonably be considered a reputational risk. One could argue, quite plausibly, that Europe’s reputation and institutional legitimacy are far more threatened by illiberal policies aimed at suppressing civil society and democratic pluralism, while transforming European institutions into a playground for industrial lobbies defending private interests against the common good.
The political nature of the SWG was openly acknowledged by one of the document’s co-authors, EPP MEP Dirk Gotink, as early as February 2026:
“The problem that we’re pursuing here is not to establish whether things are illegal; it is to establish whether politically it is undesirable.”
Among the activities deemed politically undesirable, and supposedly constituting a reputational risk, are some of the most basic forms of democratic advocacy, including “sending letters, organising meetings or providing advocacy material to EU institutions or specific members of an institution” (p. 20). The document also flags as a possible reputational risk the production of position papers, the provision of technical and scientific expertise to institutions, and even participation in public consultations. These are the basic, lawful and legitimate activities of any stakeholder or organisation engaging in public affairs.
There is no other way to put it: the authors of the SWG seek to muzzle civil society and silence any dissenting voice capable of serving as a counterweight to private and industrial lobbying interests, or acting as an effective watchdog for compliance with EU law. The document states this in black and white. Activities identified as constituting reputational risk include “[providing] voting recommendations and counterarguments to balance industry’s influence” and pursuing legal action and litigation against Member States and EU institutions when they breach the law. The SWG is thus explicitly aligned with the interests of powerful lobbying actors and operates in a manner that discourages legal accountability and independent scrutiny.
BLOOM calls on all MEPs, specifically those of the EPP who still care about European values and the rule of law, to denounce this text and press their CONT colleagues to reject it.