BLOOM Association

Determined to fight the destruction of the ocean, the climate, and livelihoods

A small, powerful expert NGO whose only satisfaction is results

Take action Donate

10 December 2025

Death in EU supermarkets’ value chain: NGOs sound the alarm as EU corporate sustainability laws are being dismantled

One day after the disastrous trilogue on the European Omnibus I directive, during which Heads of Government, Members of the European Parliament, and the European Commission agreed to dismantle the EU corporate sustainability due diligence law, a key pillar of the Green Deal designed to support the social and ecological transition of large companies in the European Union, the release of the film Death at Sea by Human Rights at Sea supported by the Blue Marine Foundation and the Sustainable Fisheries and Communities Trust comes at just the right time to illustrate the tangible consequences of this political strategic mistake. The movie documents a family’s relentless pursuit of justice for Eritara Aati Kaierua, a tuna-industry worker who died under suspicious circumstances aboard a Taiwanese vessel in the Pacific in March 2020. His story showcases the dangerous conditions of workers at sea and demonstrates the importance of the corporate sustainability legislation now being dismantled.

Five years after the death of Eritara Aati Kaierua on the tuna vessel ‘WIN FAR 636’, and despite an investigation by the Kiribati authorities following an autopsy concluding that it was a homicide, the family is still waiting for answers, justice and compensation. In parallel, the tuna vessel was allowed to resume activities after having paid a security payment of USD 100,000. It was further able to recover its MSC ‘sustainable fishery’ certificate just a few months later. Among others, the vessel is linked to one ubiquitous supplier of western supermarkets: Thai Union, which owns the brands Petit Navire (France), John West (UK), Mareblu (Italy), and produces tuna cans for supermakets’ private labels.

BLOOM and Human Rights at Sea denounce the apparent mismanagement of the investigation by the Kiribati authorities, the continued refusal of the Taiwanese authorities to open an investigation as per their flag state responsibilities, and the general lack of effective preventive measures put in place by food retailers in their supply chains to prevent these risks. The two NGOs have alerted UK and French main food retailers, which ought to investigate their supply chain in accordance with their due diligence, and if applicable, ensure the compensation of the family and the implementation of corrective measures at supplier level.

The systemic failure of the fishing industry to safeguard human rights at sea epitomized by the multiple deaths of government-mandated scientific observers

Eritara Aati Kaierua was a tuna fishery observer mandated by the Kiribati government when he died between the 3rd and the 4th of March 2020. As a scientific observer, he was on a mission to observe and report on the legal compliance of the practices (1) perpetrated aboard the Taiwanese tuna purse seiner. His story, meticulously documented by Human Rights at Sea (2) and narrated in Sara Pipernos’ movie Death at Sea (3) released today, is a stark example the excessively dangerous conditions in which workers at sea operate, often to produce fish that ends up on European and American supermarket shelves. (4)  

The fishing industry is one of the most dangerous industries in the world. The International Labour Organization estimates that 128,000 fishers were subject to forced labour in 2021, and that this number is very likely underestimated. (5) As for the tuna industry specifically, despite being the most lucrative fishing sector in the world with a cumulated turnover of more than 43 billion dollars in 2024, (6) it concentrates abuses: a meta-analysis found that 42% of human rights violations at sea occur on tuna vessels (7). The race to profits in this largely unregulated industry (8) pushes industry-players to cut costs, including working costs at the expense of the safety and the preservation of human rights at sea. (9)  

Fisheries observers, as authorities’ agents, are particularly at risk since their reports could lead to substantial fines affecting fisheries’ licence to operate and costs. Despite their official status, at least nineteen observers have officially disappeared in suspicious circumstances over the past fifteen years. (10)  

The complicity of authorities with the fishing industry surrounding Eritara’s death

Human rights at Sea’s investigation of Eritara Aati Kaierua’s death (11) showcases the failure of authorities to systemically protect human rights at sea, and their assessed occasional complicity with fishing industry players to uphold the truth while ensuring to minimize impact on business activities.   

Eritara’s death occurred while the WIN FAR 636 was operating in international waters in the Pacific. According to the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), Taiwan is therefore the competent jurisdiction, as the ship was flying its flag. Despite numerous inquiries, no investigation has been opened. 

In the meantime, the Kiribati authorities, for which Eritara was working, opened an investigation. However, like in many other observer disappearances before, it got closed in opaque and suspicious circumstances, with many unanswered questions. Human Rights at Sea’s research (12) highlights major blind spots and interferences that compromise the integrity of this official investigation. 

  • Official examinations have been contradicted by opaque industry-mandated counter-expertise: the initial autopsy of Eritara’s body was conducted shortly after his death by a forensic pathologist assigned by the Kiribati authorities and concluded that it was a homicide. Since then, it has been successfully contested by the owner of the vessel, who commissioned two additional forensic examinations. These appear to have been conducted remotely, without access to the body, in conditions incompatible with scientific rigor. Their conclusions subsequently reclassified the death as “natural”. The family, who attempted to obtain the full reports, never gained access to them, whereas the vessel owners’ lawyer received copies. 
  • Key elements of the investigation are retained by authorities or have disappeared: the family has yet to receive the results of the DNA analyses on the crime scene and the data contained in the electronic devices seized on board. Eritara’s working daily journal was returned to his family, with the last pages – certainly containing compromising information on the vessel’s practices – torn apart. 
  • Despite remaining questions, the vessel was allowed to resume activities: following the reception of the results of the counter-forensic expertise mandated by the vessel owner, the WIN FAR 636 was able to return to sea six months after its suspension, paying a security payment of USD 100,000 and without any Court Order sanctioning its release.  

The ineffectiveness of supermarkets’ ‘sustainable’ sourcing practices

The WIN FAR 636 was – and still is – certified ‘sustainable’ by the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC). (13) It sells its tuna to large traders with links to main tuna manufacturers, European brands and supermarkets. Most European retailers have ‘sustainable’ sourcing policies which BLOOM has already analysed: for the vast majority, these are highly ineffective and hide retailers’ wilful ignorance of the fishing industry’s systematic risks. (14) Eritara is one of the many collateral victims of a largely defaulting system, including due to corporations’ current unaccountability. 

The MSC is the most widespread so-called seafood sustainability scheme worldwide, with over 20% of global wild catches being engaged with its standard in 2025. (15) This blue-tick logo is ubiquitous on supermarket shelves, with more than eight European retailers out of ten using it to claim that their sourcing of fish comes from sustainable fishing practices. (16) It has however been denounced for years due to its misleading nature: it certifies high-impact destructive fisheries that are incompatible with a sustainable fishing practice (17) and it is unfit to protect fishing industry workers at sea and on land. (18), (19)  

The WIN FAR 636 is linked to EU supermarkets via different tuna manufacturers (20), including the global giant Thai Union which manufactures and markets the leading French and British brands Petit Navire and John West, along supermarkets’ private labels. Among others, it is also linked to Frinsa and Princes Group, which produce large quantities of canned tuna to European supermarkets.  

The need for corporate due diligence to ensure accountability of industry players and the improvement of practices

Despite most supermarkets claiming to operate according to the UN Guiding Principles on Human Rights, to our knowledge, no retailer had taken action to clarify the circumstances surrounding Eritara’s death before BLOOM and Human Rights at Sea’s alert on 2 December 2025. Both organisations called on leading British (21) and French (22) supermarkets to fulfil their due diligence obligations and investigate the link between Eritara’s death and their supply chain. They shall publish the result of their investigation and if applicable, ensure the compensation of his family and the implementation of corrective measures at supplier level. To date, Marks & Spencer is the only retailer that has responded providing sufficient elements to ensure its activities were not linked to the WIN FAR 636.  

According to Pauline Bricault, Markets campaign manager at BLOOM, “Although incredibly dreadful, Eritara’s death comes as no surprise to BLOOM. Our research shows that retailer ‘sustainable’ sourcing practices are ineffective to protect human rights at sea. They rely on declarative data, do not audit vessels, nor engage with local unions or develop effective grievance mechanisms. At best, they ensure the presence of observers, which we know can operate in life-threatening circumstances. Consumers should not bear the responsibility of making ethical purchasing decisions as supermarkets should offer only products free from any form of abuse. And thanks to years of NGO campaigning efforts, France pioneered a legal obligation for large companies to implement due diligence in their supply chain, ensuring corporate accountability and the acceleration of the improved practices. It is based on this law that BLOOM and foodwatch took Carrefour – the French leading global supermarket chain – to court in March 2025 for failure to comply with its due diligence in its tuna supply chain. (23) Legal due diligence is one of the last actionable and effective means available to ensure retailer and industry accountability. The current dismantling of the equivalent of our French due diligence law at the European level with the Omnibus I directive is a terrible fallback which will have dire consequences. On 11 and 16 of December, European members of Parliament must reject the Omnibus I directive, at the very least in respect for Eritara’s death and all the other ones he represents.”

To go further:  
  • Reports from Human Rights at Sea  
  • 01/07/2020: Independent report – Fisheries observer deaths at sea, human rights & the role & responsibilities of fisheries organisations, available here  
  • 19/05/2021 : Independent review – Independent case review into the investigation of the death of kiribati fisheries observer Eritara Aati Kaierua, available here 
  • CCTV Footage – images from the WIN FAR 636 before and after the incident, where crew members can be seen carrying Eritara’s body, available here  

NOTES

(1) Please see more about the role of observers at sea here : available here

(2) HRAS, 2021, Death at Sea. Independent Case Review of Kiribati Fisheries Observer Eritara Aati Kaierua, available here 

(3) Death at Sea, available here 

(4) Financial Times, 2025, The dark truth behind supermarket tuna, available here 

(5) ILO, 2022, Global Estimates of Modern Slavery : Forced Labour and Forced Marriage, see page 33, available here

(6) Fortune Business Insights, 2025, Tuna Fish Market Size, Share & Industry Analysis, available here 

(7) Study of 6,853 international offences at sea between 2000 and 2020, see Belhabid et al. (2022), Fish crimes in the global oceans, Science advances, DOI:10.1126/ sciadv.abj1927, available here

(8) BLOOM, 2023, Eyes Wide Shut, available here 

(9) BLOOM, 2023, Canned brutality, available here 

(10) Association for Professional Observers, Observer Deaths and Disappearances, available here 

(11) HRAS, 2021, Death at Sea. Independent Case Review of Kiribati Fisheries Observer Eritara Aati Kaierua, available here 

(12) HRAS, 2021, Independent case review into the investigation of the death of kiribati fisheries observer Eritara Aati Kaierua, available here 

(13) SCS Global services, WPSTA Western and Central Pacific Skipjack, Yellowfin, and Bigeye Purse Seine Fishery MSC Fishery Assessment Report, available here

(14) BLOOM, 2023, Willfuf ignorance, available here 

(15) MSC, available here 

(16) BLOOM, 2023, Willful ignorance, available here

(17) BLOOM, 2024, 11 Golden rules or truly social-ecological fisheries, available here 

(18) The Outlaw Ocean Project, “China, the superpower of seafood: findings”, available here 

(19) BLOOM, 2024, 11 Golden rules or truly social-ecological fisheries, available here

(20) BLOOM, 2024, 11 Golden rules or truly social-ecological fisheries, available here

(21) The 10 largest British retailers contacted: Aldi South (UK), Asda, Co-op, Iceland, Lidl, Morrisons, M&S, Sainsbury’s, Tesco, Waitrose

(22) The ten largest French retailers contacted: Aldi (Nord) France, Auchan Retail, Carrefour, Casino, E. Leclerc, Les Mousquetaires, Lidl, Métro, Monoprix, Système U

(23) https://www.bloomassociation.org/en/tuna-bloom-and-foodwatch-take-carrefour-to-court/