BLOOM Association

Determined to fight the destruction of the ocean, the climate, and livelihoods

A small, powerful expert NGO whose only satisfaction is results

Take action Donate

29 April 2025

Brittany’s Brexit Bounty: the scandal of French fisheries aid

Following up on the blatant inequalities in the allocation of COVID aid in 2021,(1) BLOOM reveals a new financial scandal linked to public subsidies granted to the fishing industry in France. Our ground-breaking investigation, “Brittany’s Brexit Bounty”, shows how the fishing industry based in Brittany got its hands on Brexit aid at the expense of other regions, which were on the front lines when it came to the closure of British waters. This once again illustrates the unacceptable joint management of public money and natural resources by the government and industrial fishing lobbies.

Our detailed analysis of how the decrees of 30 September and 14 November 2022 established a subsidy scheme in the context of Brexit,(2) shows the scandalous way in which a subsequent amendment to the original text lifted the restriction limiting aid to small and medium-sized businesses only, and opened the floodgates of public funding to industrial fishing vessels. As a result, around ten shipowners received half of the subsidies, and the industrial fleets of Brittany struck gold. Indeed, Brittany alone received three times as much public money as the Hauts-de-France region, proportionally to the size of their respective fleets. Intermarché’s fleet, Scapêche, was the first to benefit from the amended decree, raking in €11 million, i.e. 19% of the fund.

Our work also shows the perverse mechanisms by which public aid is diverted from its intended purpose of reducing fleet capacity, which remains chronically excessive given the current state of the ocean. For example, the trawl company “La Houle” received €3.9 million to dismantle just four vessels, while at the same time committing to renewing its fleet, in a blatant circumvention of the rules on public subsidies. The Intermarché’s fishing fleet has also publicly stated the same intention.

This exceptional financial aid to a sector that is already heavily subsidised should have helped to trigger the social and ecological transition of part of France’s fishing industry, boosting the resilience of these businesses in the face of the ocean’s deteriorating health, climate change, and an increasing number of crises. This was not the case.

On the contrary, a small number of industrial companies have captured most of the public resources, locking in the destructive trawling model, which goes against the general interest, environmental protection, and a genuine transition of the sector towards more socially and ecologically sustainable fishing practices. Moreover, such a transition can only take place if the fishing quotas of the decommissioned vessels are reallocated to small coastal vessels.

BLOOM stresses that the inevitable phasing out of trawlers in the fisheries sector must be carried out under a gradual transition plan with clear, transparent and jointly agreed rules, to support social justice and prioritise the most vulnerable fishers who are not backed by industrial fleets. Yet, as always, those who pull the political strings in Paris and Brussels are those who benefit most from public wealth. The industry lobbies that oppose protecting the ocean and the social and ecological transition of the sector are also those that are now calling for massive subsidies to renew the fleet, and for European regulations to be amended to allow an increase in fishing capacity.

>>> Read our report ‘Brittany’s Brexit Bounty’ <<<

As part of the Brexit Adjustment Reserve (BAR) adopted by the European Union, the French government introduced an Individual Support Plan (ISP) in 2022 to compensate fishers affected by the closure of British waters and the reduction in quotas as a result of Brexit, in return for dismantling one or more of their vessels.(3) The aim of this aid was to stop fishing for good, and therefore to reduce fleet capacity, which has been chronically excessive given the state of the ocean. A total of 86 vessels were dismantled, at a cost of €58 million.

Our analysis of this fund shows that the government sub- sequently amended the decree setting out the aid’s eligibility criteria to open up access to the largest companies. As a result, it was able to subsidise as many vessels as possible, even those that had not necessarily been impacted by Brexit. This is how one of France’s top retailers, Intermarché, enabled its own fleet, Scapêche, to emerge as the big winner in this distribution of public wealth, receiving nearly €11 million to scrap seven vessels. Three of these vessels had been fishing in deep waters for years,(4) one of them in breach of the law.(5)

Overall, around a dozen shipowners took half of the subsidies, i.e. €28.3 million out of a total budget of €58 million. Coming second on the list of companies from Brittany that have landed the lion’s share of this financial windfall is La Houle, a company that owns several trawlers. La Houle received nearly €3.9 million to scrap four of its vessels.(6) In the months leading up to the introduction of this subsidy plan, this shipowner publicly announced its fleet renewal strategy in the press, in anticipation of public aid, and in full knowledge of the rules prohibiting beneficiaries of Brexit subsidies from registering or fitting out new vessels for five years. This strategy is also publicly endorsed by Intermarché’s fleet, Scapêche.(7)

Although Brexit aid did facilitate the scrapping of around 50 trawlers, it did not initiate the necessary social and ecological transition of the fishing industry. Not only did some fishing companies circumvent the rules in order to invest in new vessels, but the government made no real commitment to reallocating quotas from scrapped vessels (8) to vessels using more sustainable, non-trawling methods.

Our study calls for a complete overhaul of the governance of the fishing industry, which is condemned to ruin by a management system that runs counter to the interests of French citizens and small-scale fishers. This system is characterised by collusion between the State and a minority of industrial stakeholders, with a fishing model that is entirely dependent on trawling and other fishing methods that are energy-intensive, destructive, loss-making, and propped up by public subsidies.

************************************

NOTES

(1) BLOOM, 2021. Analysis of COVID fisheries subsidies : the davastating favouritisme of the French government.

(2) Arrêté du 30 septembre 2022 relatif à la mise en œuvre d’un plan d’accompagnement individuel dans le cadre du retrait du Royaume-Uni de Grande-Bretagne et d’Irlande du Nord de l’Union européenne.

(3) Arrêté du 30 septembre 2022 relatif à la mise en œuvre d’un plan d’accompagnement individuel dans le cadre du retrait du Royaume-Uni de Grande-Bretagne et d’Irlande du Nord de l’Union européenne.

(4) The Jean-Claude Coulon II, the Roselend and the Corail.

(5) Read our scientific paper revealing massive fraud by deep-sea trawlers (January 2025).

(6) The Horizon, the Buccin and the Jusant.

(7) Le Marin, 2023. « La Scapêche est un armement hauturier et ambitionne de le rester ».

(8) Following a fleet exit plan, 70% of the historic fishing rights of the dismantled vessels are allocated to the reserves of producer organizations, and 30% are allocated to a national reserve managed by the Directorate-General for Maritime Affairs, Fisheries and Aquaculture (DGAMPA).